15 Comments
User's avatar
Amy Makechnie's avatar

Keep the faith! I've been there...it's a numbers game, not personal. The more you pitch, the luckier you get :) I have several yellow legal pads FILLED with agents queried and me being rejected. I kept asking, and I learned to follow-up with, "If you have anyone you'd recommend for me to pitch, I would so appreciate it." or something like that. I would most likely not get an answer back, but sometimes I did - and that led me to my current agent, who likely read my book bc a colleague had personally recommended it (fair or not, a personal recommendation is gold). Keep going! It will happen.

Expand full comment
Paige Geiger's avatar

I hadn’t heard to follow up…can’t hurt! Thank you for the encouragement. I’m prepared for the long road ahead, but trying to enjoy other aspects of writing (here) in the meantime!

Expand full comment
Amy Makechnie's avatar

Good! That’s imp. I should also add, this was only successful when they had requested at least a partial to read and then rejected. I’ve seen literary agents write, “DON’T ask for a recommendation…” but if it’s phrased more like “if you had a colleague or contact that you could recommend to query I would so appreciate…” The worst that happens is they simply don’t reply. Happy weekend!

Expand full comment
Sarah Lavender Smith's avatar

I am not in the query trenches yet—still drafting my memoir—but I appreciate you chronicling your experience and being transparent about the disappointments. Don't give up!

Expand full comment
Paige Geiger's avatar

Thank you Sarah! I'm excited for you to get to the next step...we should really think about exchanging pages at some point. Let me know if you have a need for a reader...I already know I love your writing!

Expand full comment
Sarah Lavender Smith's avatar

Thank you :-)

Expand full comment
Mel's avatar

I hear you Paige and you've got the perfect outlook. It is so rare for a writer to get picked up quickly. What you have is a winner's attitude and you understand the power of having grit. We just need to keep going.

My stats: 12 sent, 4 nos, 8 no response. I'm about to send another round out within the next couple of weeks.

Expand full comment
Paige Geiger's avatar

It takes so much grit! And writing friends that support your every move...we got this! I love that we're doing this together...we can talk about it someday on a podcast or book tour :)

Expand full comment
Andrea Bartz's avatar

Thanks for sharing my query-letter compendium!

Expand full comment
Paige Geiger's avatar

You are very welcome...such a great resource! It has already given me so many ideas to revise my letter.

Expand full comment
Andrea Bartz's avatar

I'm so glad!

Expand full comment
Victoria Christensen's avatar

As a scientist as well, I get where you are coming from. You get thick skin from failures and critiques. The rejections roll off. I can't give you query numbers (in the 100s), but I took a different path and had published books before an agent.

Expand full comment
Paige Geiger's avatar

Definitely thick skin. And I love that you are also a scientist! I want to know more about your publishing journey (and if you've written about it, please send me a link). Are you with an agent now or self-publishing? I am open to all paths and not ruling anything out.

Expand full comment
Victoria Christensen's avatar

I have an agent now. I am traditionally published, which is a lot easier for me in terms of marketing etc because I still work full time. It has been a wild ride, that's for sure.

Expand full comment
Paige Geiger's avatar

I also work full time and that is a reason I want you to publish traditionally (it takes so many skills to put a book in the world and I’d really love a team!). Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment